Legal Update
Cash pooling in rough waters: Beware of selective payments!
Within a group of companies, the bank balances of the various entities are often swept together automatically on a daily basis through a cash pool. But what happens when the bankruptcy of one or more of the participating companies is on the horizon? In a judgment of 6 October 2026 (ECLI:NL:GHARL:2026:6407, in Dutch), the Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal held that, in certain circumstances, cash pooling may constitute a selective payment for which the director can be held personally liable. What does this judgment mean in practice?
What happened?
Two operating companies and their parent company participated in a zero-balancing cash pool. Credit balances of the operating companies were automatically transferred to the parent company every day. Conversely, the parent topped up any debit balances. The parent company consistently set off the amounts received against its own claims on the operating companies.
The cash pool continued to operate while the director knew, or ought to have known, that the operating companies were heading for bankruptcy. As a result, the parent company kept receiving payments while other creditors went unpaid. According to the Court, the director was personally seriously culpable (persoonlijk ernstig verwijt). The parent company also acted unlawfully by continuing to participate in the cash pooling. Both were ordered to pay more than €243,000 to the bankruptcy trustee.
Does it matter that the transfers were made automatically? No. The director knew how the cash pool operated and, according to the Court, deliberately allowed it to continue for the benefit of the parent company.
When is selective payment unlawful?
In principle, a company is free to choose which creditors it pays, even if there is not enough money to pay everyone. That freedom has its limits, however, particularly where payments to group companies are concerned. Has a company decided to cease its activities and is it unable to pay all its creditors? Then, in principle, it may not pay a group company in preference to others.
The director is personally liable if he or she can be held seriously culpable. That may be the case if the director knew or ought to have known that the payments would result in other creditors going unpaid.
What does this mean in practice?
A cash pool need not be terminated immediately when financial difficulties arise, but the cash flows should be reassessed. Who is receiving the money? Is it being used to repay debts owed to a group company? And what is left for other creditors?
Pay attention to the finance documentation as well. Cash pooling agreements often contain joint and several liability as well as set-off and security rights in favour of the bank, and amending or terminating the pool may have consequences under the financing. Assess in good time whether the cash pool needs to be amended or terminated, involve the bank where necessary and record the considerations. Do not wait until the formal decision to file for bankruptcy.
Would you like to know more about cash pooling generally or selective payments in times of financial distress? Please feel free to contact one of our specialists.